GOD AND INDIVIDUAL PERSONS Cover Image

БОГ И ОТДЕЛЬНЫЕ ЛИЧНОСТИ
GOD AND INDIVIDUAL PERSONS

Author(s): Pavel Butakov
Subject(s): Ancient Philosphy, Philosophy of Religion
Published by: Новосибирский государственный университет
Keywords: divine hiddenness; Schellenberg; divine love; ancient theology; collective subject;

Summary/Abstract: The atheistic Hiddenness Argument contains a controversial premise that a perfectly loving God would love every single person. J. L. Schellenberg, the author of the Argument, claims that this premise is necessarily true. However, many ancient theologians would disagree with the truth of this premise. In this paper, I provide evidence of the variety of alternative theological views from antiquity concerning the proper object of perfect divine love. The list of alternatives includes 1) the whole humanity as a collective subject, 2) humanity as a universal, 3) divine image reflected in human beings, 4) the community of the faithful, 5) a chosen people. Based on the disagreement between Schellenberg and the ancient theologians concerning the proper object of perfect divine love, I argue that the aforementioned premise of the hiddenness argument, even if true, is not necessarily true. Therefore, the key premise of the hiddenness argument turns out to be without support, and the Argument turns out to be unsound.

  • Issue Year: XV/2021
  • Issue No: 2
  • Page Range: 966-977
  • Page Count: 12
  • Language: Russian
Toggle Accessibility Mode