Removing an Inconsistency from Jago’s Theory of Truth Cover Image

Removing an Inconsistency from Jago’s Theory of Truth
Removing an Inconsistency from Jago’s Theory of Truth

Author(s): Nathan William Davies
Subject(s): Philosophy, Ethics / Practical Philosophy
Published by: Filozofický ústav SAV
Keywords: Truth; truthmaking; proposition; state of affairs; explanation; redundancy;

Summary/Abstract: I identify an inconsistency in Jago’s theory of truth. I show that Jago is committed to the identity of the proposition that the proposition that A is true and the proposition that A. I show that Jago is committed to the proposition that A being true because A if the proposition that A is true. I show that these two commitments, given the rest of Jago’s theory, entail a contradiction. I show that while the latter commitment follows from Jago’s theory of truth, even by Jago’s own lights he should not be committed to the identity of the proposition that the proposition that A is true and the proposition that A.

  • Issue Year: 30/2023
  • Issue No: 4
  • Page Range: 339-349
  • Page Count: 11
  • Language: English
Toggle Accessibility Mode