ПАРАДОКС ЛЖЕЦА И ПЕРВАЯ ТЕОРЕМА ГЕДЕЛЯ О НЕПОЛНОТЕ
THE LIAR PARADOX AND GODEL’S FIRST INCOMPLETENESS THEOREM
Author(s): VITALY TSELISHCEVSubject(s): Logic, Ancient Philosphy
Published by: Новосибирский государственный университет
Keywords: Liar paradox; Godel’s theorem; explication; truth predicate; self-reference;
Summary/Abstract: The article critically analyzes the example of the incorrect application of metamathematics, in particular, Gödel's First incompleteness theorem, to the explication of the Liar Paradox by J. Barker. It is shown that an explication of this kind, doubting well known Tarki’s definition of truth, is based on the erroneous use of key Gödel constructions - substitution idea and the diagonal lemma. The criticism of the proclamation by Barker of the explication of the Liar as a mathematical theorem shows certain limitations in demonstrating the heuristic analogy between the Liar's sentence and the Godelian sentence.
Journal: ΣΧΟΛΗ. Философское антиковедение и классическая традиция
- Issue Year: XI/2017
- Issue No: 2
- Page Range: 415-427
- Page Count: 13
- Language: Russian