The Narrowness of Wide-Scope Principles
The Narrowness of Wide-Scope Principles
Author(s): David BottingSubject(s): Logic
Published by: Filozofický ústav SAV
Keywords: Coherence; counterfactual conditionals; modus ponens – Ramsey test; rationality; wide and narrow scope conditionals;
Summary/Abstract: In this paper I will propose that the unpalatable consequences of narrowscope principles are not avoided by altering the scope of the principle but by changing the kind of conditional. I argue that a counterfactual conditional should do the trick and that the rational requirement of modus ponens can be understood as something like a “Ramsey test” on this conditional.
Journal: Organon F
- Issue Year: 23/2016
- Issue No: 2
- Page Range: 177-203
- Page Count: 27
- Language: English