WHAT KINDS OF DISAGREEMENT ARE INTROSPECTIVE DISPUTES?
WHAT KINDS OF DISAGREEMENT ARE INTROSPECTIVE DISPUTES?
Author(s): Bruno MölderSubject(s): Epistemology, Philosophy of Language, Phenomenology
Published by: Teaduste Akadeemia Kirjastus
Keywords: introspective disputes; introspection; phenomenal character; experience of time; deep disagreement; verbal disagreement; metalinguistic disagreement; faultless disagreement;
Summary/Abstract: Introspective disputes are introspectively based disputes about features of experiences. This paper addresses the question of what kinds of disagreement are exemplified in such disputes. The following kinds of disagreement are reviewed with respect to introspective disputes – verbal, metalinguistic, faultless, deep and genuine disagreements. The paper defends the conclusion that introspective debates are genuine debates that are mostly of the theoretical kind and that some such debates may also involve metalinguistic negotiation.
Journal: TRAMES
- Issue Year: XXIV/2020
- Issue No: 3
- Page Range: 363-380
- Page Count: 18
- Language: English