A Scientific Transcript of Parliamentarism Cover Image

Znanstvena transkripcija parlamentarizma
A Scientific Transcript of Parliamentarism

Author(s): Davor Rodin
Subject(s): Political Theory, Government/Political systems
Published by: Fakultet političkih znanosti u Zagrebu
Keywords: political systems; parliamentarism; Carl Schmitt;

Summary/Abstract: According to Carl Schmitt, liberal parliamentarism and democracy are founded on conflicting principles. The first is founded upon the principle of rational deliberation, that is, upon the idea that political will in a modem country is formed through rational discussion, the latter is based upon power as an instrument of political activity which homogenizes the national majority and eliminates divergent minorities. Schmitt considers that the principle of power is taking over deliberation in modem countries, and thus abandones the conditions for liberal parliamentarism. On another level, Schmitt argues that the contrast of deliberation and power is repeated within liberal-democratic institutions as division of powers between the multi-party parliament which fosters rational discussion, and executive power which is the instrument of political activity and must be legitimized in parliament. The weakness of liberal democracies is the empowering of those political forces (fascism, communism) that reject political dialogue as a process of competition between various platforms in front of the electorate, but they rather, see it as a means of imposing a single, self-serving truth. The author concludes that Schmitt has missed the key dimension of liberal democracy, because his critique is based upon an outdated, Neokantian methodological position. As the analog to Rickert’s nomothetic science, Schmitt in his political theory opposes rational generalizations and irrational content. However, the main point is that liberal political science as a constituent part of the political process operates between two political media, speech and action, without destroying plurality of political positions.

  • Issue Year: XXX/1993
  • Issue No: 04
  • Page Range: 105-117
  • Page Count: 13
  • Language: Croatian
Toggle Accessibility Mode